A natural diamond in the one-carat size range can come with a very different asking price than it did in 2023. For round diamonds weighing 1.00–1.19 carats, with G color and VS1 clarity, PriceScope reported an average retail price of $8,541 per carat in January 2023. Its November 2026 report puts the same category at $4,711 per carat.

That is $3,830 less per carat across the two snapshots, using the same source, shape, weight band, color and clarity.

The dollar comparison

The earlier figure comes from PriceScope’s January 2023 report, published January 15, 2023. The later figure appears in its November 2026 report, published November 2, using data updated November 1.

Both figures are US dollars per carat, not the price of a finished engagement ring. These are listed-price averages for a defined category, not a record of one identical diamond being sold twice. The category includes stones above exactly one carat; a larger stone’s total price must account for its actual weight.

The figures also are not resale offers. Someone who bought a diamond in 2023 cannot use this comparison alone to calculate what a jeweler would pay for it today.

What the headline does not tell you

Matching carat range, color and clarity makes the comparison more useful than a generic “one-carat diamond” claim. It does not make every stone interchangeable. PriceScope notes that cut quality, grading laboratory, fluorescence, proportions and the mix of available inventory can affect an average.

GIA’s quality guide explains that a diamond’s value depends on the combination of the 4Cs: carat weight, color, clarity and cut. Proportions influence light performance; weight alone does not tell you how bright or attractive a diamond will look.

For buyers, the practical takeaway is straightforward: use the lower category average as context, then compare the actual stones, grading reports, photographs and seller terms. The dollar shift is real in this reported category. The best purchase still depends on the diamond in front of you.

About the author

Erica Diggs is a GIA Graduate Gemologist, bench jeweler, CAD designer and diamond setter, and the founder and editor of Drip With Diggs.