On Oct. 20, Tara Sinchuri, 52, was killed inside Everest Jewels in Fairfield, Ohio, during a robbery. Fairfield police say two men entered shortly before 1 p.m. and spoke with Sinchuri as if they intended to make a purchase. The men then produced firearms, and a struggle followed. Sinchuri was killed, and the suspects took valuables from the store before fleeing, according to police. [1]

Butler County Prosecutor Mike Gmoser told FOX19 that Sinchuri fought back. The police account says a struggle occurred. [1][2]

Police announced Nov. 13 that Carlos Idrogo-Arias had been arrested in New York City on Nov. 4 and was awaiting extradition to Ohio. Investigators also identified Richard Guzman-Guzman as a second suspect, whom police believe may be in the New York or New Jersey area. Police say he should be considered armed and dangerous. [1]

The killing has added to a troubling year for jewelry-industry workers. The Jewelers’ Security Alliance says Sinchuri was the third industry worker killed on the job in 2026. JSA’s 2025 crime report recorded two such deaths in 2025. [3][4]

Safety comes before merchandise

JSA’s robbery guidance is direct: do not resist during a robbery and do not chase the robbers. Its report notes that jewelry-store robbers may carry weapons and use force. [4]

For store owners, that advice belongs in a written plan employees can recall under pressure. Train staff on how to alert authorities, where customers and employees should move, and how to respond once the immediate danger has passed. Jewelers Mutual also recommends documenting the incident and notifying the insurer promptly. [5]

The valuables can be inventoried after people are safe. A practiced, safety-first response gives staff a clear priority in a moment when seconds matter.